We reviewed the iPhone version of this game a long time ago, but we thought it was only fair that we return and take a look at the Android version, as it does have some notable differences from the iOS iteration that we think Android football/soccer fans should know about before parting with their cash.
After all, this Android release is far more expensive than the iPhone version. So, you would think it must surely add some extra content and features to justify the extra cost? You would think so, but in a similar fashion to PES 2012, which shipped for Android with missing multiplayer that was present and correct in the iOS version, here Android football fans are again being charged more for less.
FIFA 12 has a lot to live up to. The previous FIFA 11 was a decent football game, perhaps the best the series has produced on mobile so far, but still some way off Pro Evolution Soccer, with the Konami game really enjoying itself on the new format. There is even the spectre of Real Football, as Gameloft’s fledgling series has hit the ground running ever since its first iteration.
Thankfully, FIFA 12 does live up to expectations, and is perhaps the most realistic and satisfying football/soccer game yet released for a smartphone, although it does have a big, wide glaring omission, but more on that later.
The first major change, and the most important for FIFA fans, is that the gameplay and the feel of the game is now very close to what you would expect on a home console. FIFA 12 has a context sensitive control system, based around three virtual buttons that allow you to perform almost every pass or shot imaginable. Stroking a lofted pass out to the wing now looks and feels as it should, and through balls, both on the ground and in the air feel natural and perfectly balanced. This is helped massively by the improved player A.I. with teammates making space and performing runs in a way that is very impressive.
I think the great thing about the context sensitive buttons is that each button isnt confined to ‘pass’, ‘shoot’ and run, but are really mixed up. Tapping the shoot button does as you would expect, and dragging up from the shoot button performs the expected lob, but you can drag down from the pass button to try a finesse shot. The run button is also well used, and it is this intelligence of control that makes the game feel so good.
It is a shame that the goalkeeping is so terrible. Even on the hardest difficulty the goalies will have trouble saving any shots. It is a real shame, as it does spoil things somewhat when you can shoot from near the halfway line and score more often than not.
Defending isn’t as impressive, but does a job. The buttons are again context sensitive, and it is possible to really pressurize your opponent, although I feel more could have been done here. It is quite difficult to test the defensive side of the game as there is no way of playing against another human…
The touchscreen is used well in set pieces such as free kicks, where you can simply touch the player you want to try to pass to, or swipe the screen to try a shot. It’s a good combination, and shows that EA have been thinking about how to improve all aspects of the game.
There is a nice smattering of game modes, such as a quick match and a clever daily challenge, but the mode I’m sure most of you will be spending your time in is the manager mode. Yes, manager mode is now mobile, and you can take your favourite team and micro manage to your hearts content. All the main options are present and correct, including a worldwide transfer market, the ability to alter every aspect of your line up and strategy, and even the ability to upgrade your stadium and staff. The manager mode here is actually better than last years console efforts, although not quite as thorough as this years PS3/Xbox efforts.
There is a big thing missing though, and that is any kind of multiplayer action of any sort. Yes, there is no online, Wi-Fi or even BlueTooth included at all, which to be honest is a big disappointment. You can hook the iPhone version to the iPad title and use the iPhone as a controller but really; wouldn’t the time have been better spent creating a simple two player Bluetooth mode?
The graphics are smooth and good looking, although I have to say the players look horrible up close. The commentary is great, and while there is no Game Center support there is the option of connecting to EA’s own Origin service and the game does have its fair share of achievements, some of which are linked to the daily challenge feature.
Overall, this is an excellent game of football, with great gameplay and fantastic manager mode. The experience is marred by the dodgy goalkeepers and total lack of multiplayer modes, but this is still a must buy for any iPhone toting footie fan.
The first thing I have to mention is that there has been no multiplayer mode added to this Android release, which is as maddening as it was on iPhone, but that loss has been compounded by an even more mystifying omission- manager mode. Yes, you read that correctly, the brilliant career and manager mode has disappeared from this version. The only reason I can think of for its absence is because EA have to host the extra data download, and a manager mode would have increased this a lot, but whatever the reason it is a major feature that is missing from FIFA 12 for Android.
Many an Android Website would be appalled at this loss, and I am sure many Android fans will be equally upset. There are a few more problems, of a technical nature that I should mention. First of all, the sound has major issues, with crowd and commentary cutting off for no reason at all in the middle of games, and there is also the issue of Ice Cream Sandwich. If you are running ICS, I wouldn’t recommend trying this game, as there have been many problems for ICS users.
Aside from all that, the experience is similar to the iPhone version. The games plays just the same, that is to say one of the best playing football and soccer games money can buy. The graphics do seem to have been reduced in detail somewhat, but nothing that you would notice.
Overall, what we have here is a hobbled version of an excellent football game. There is still no multiplayer, and the loss of the manager mode is critical and a genuine shame for Android users. The fact that this is more expensive than the iOS version is actually a bit insulting to Android fans, and as such it deserves its low score.